British Submarine vs Italian Torpedo Boat

Published on
Review Author(s)
Book Author(s)
David Greentree
Product / Stock #
Company: Osprey Publishing - Website: Visit Site
Provided by: Osprey Publishing - Website: Visit Site
Front cover

Osprey publishing continues to expand the Duel Series, this time with WWII naval enemies: British Submarines and Italian Torpedo Boats in the Mediterranean. The Italian Torpedo Boats were more like a “destroyer escort” or “frigate”-style ship, not a fast attack torpedo craft.

This book follows the typical format of the series including a few chapters on the technical aspects of each vessel, the training of the combatants, the strategic situation, a very detailed narrative of combat, and wraps it up with statistics and analysis.

I have to say that I have found the reading of this book very interesting and I was surprised by how many references –to other books or interviews- this issue of Osprey Duel has. It is clearly an extremely well researched book and some of the main things I learned follow:

At some extent, this was a “Battle of the Atlantic” scenario, with the roles reversed. The British Navy was the hunter, and the Axis forces were the defenders of convoys. Some differences relate to the size of the convoys themselves, with only a few freighters and perhaps only two escorts. The reason for having such a small convoys was because the African ports could only handle a few ships at the time.

The Mediterranean Sea has its own challenges for combat. Due to the influx of water from the Red Sea and Atlantic, very pronounced temperature layers that would last for a few months would allow the submarines to hide from ASDIC between the layers. This seasonal effect in the water implied that the subs would become more active –and effective- during those months, which had a significant impact on the overall amount of supplies being shipped and the ground combat in the desert.

When looking at the overall number of subs and torpedo boats sunk, you might think that the torpedo boats won the battle (there were about 3 times more submarine sinkings than torpedo boats). However you should also consider that in this particular battle the submarines were mainly targeting the freighters, with a torpedo boat sinking as a secondary objective, while the torpedo boats where only targeting the submarines as their main objective.

As said before, this book is excellently well researched, has plenty of period pictures and many color profiles, plus it has two really nice full-color commissioned artworks to illustrate some specific combat situations.

Highly recommended.

I would like to thank Osprey Publishing and IPMS/USA for the review sample.


Add new comment

All comments are moderated to prevent spam

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.